一道英语趣味题(要推理哒)~Halftheapplepiew-查字典问答网
分类选择

来自刘忠玉的问题

  一道英语趣味题(要推理哒)~Halftheapplepiewasmissing,butwhohadeatenit?Thatwasthequestionmotherput.“Elainedidn’ttakeit,”Albertsaid.“AndIknowDianedidn’ttakeit,”putinBilly.“Billytookithimself,

  一道英语趣味题(要推理哒)~

  Halftheapplepiewasmissing,butwhohadeatenit?Thatwasthequestionmotherput.

  “Elainedidn’ttakeit,”Albertsaid.

  “AndIknowDianedidn’ttakeit,”putinBilly.

  “Billytookithimself,“saidCharles.

  “Dianetookit,”saidElaine.

  “Anyway,Albertdidn’ttakeit,”Dianeadded.

  Clearlysomeonemustbelying.

  Asitsoturnedout,motherdidfinallydiscoverfourofthefivechildrenhad,infact,spokenthetruth.Onlyoneofthestatementsmadewasalie.

  Whichofthefivehadstolentheapplepie?

  ()hadstolentheapplepie.

1回答
2020-04-1121:47
我要回答
提示:回答问题需要登录哦!
初忠

  这个题目给出的条件中,“Dianetookit,”和“Billytookithimself,”互相矛盾,显然有一个是真,一个是假.分别假设某一个是真,看有无矛盾.简单推出“Dianetookit,”不止一人说谎.因此Billytookithimself是真.答案是Billy.

2020-04-11 21:50:37
大家都在问
最新问答