【GMATCR,needurhelpRaymondBurrp-查字典问答网

来自洪明的问题

　　【GMATCR,needurhelpRaymondBurrplayedtheroleoflawyerPerryMasonontelevision.Burr’sdeathin1993promptedaprominentlawyertosay“Althoughnotalawyer,Mr.Burrstroveforsuchauthenticitythatwefeelasifwelostoneofourown.”】

　　GMATCR,needurhelp

　　RaymondBurrplayedtheroleoflawyerPerryMasonontelevision.Burr’sdeathin1993promptedaprominentlawyertosay“Althoughnotalawyer,Mr.Burrstroveforsuchauthenticitythatwefeelasifwelostoneofourown.”Thiscommentfromaprestigiousattorneyprovidesappallingevidencethat,inthefaceoftelevision,evensomelegalprofessionalsarelosingtheirabilitytodistinguishfictionfromreality.

　　Thereasoningintheargumentisflawedbecausetheargument

　　(A)takestheviewsofonelawyertorepresenttheviewsofalllawyers

　　(B)criticizesthelawyerratherthanthelawyer’sstatement

　　(C)presumesthatthelawyerisqualifiedtoevaluatetheperformanceofanactor

　　(D)focusesonafamousactor’sportrayalofalawyerratherthanontheusualwayinwhichlawyersareportrayedontelevision

　　(E)ignoresthepartofthelawyer’sremarkthatindicatesanawarenessofthedifferencebetweenrealityandfiction

　　Yes

　　butcouldushowwhyEiscorrectfromurreasoning?

1回答

2020-02-1623:18

我要回答

提示：回答问题需要登录哦！

提交

房立存

　　Thelawyersays:"Althoughnotalawyer,Mr.Burrstroveforsuchauthenticitythatwefeelasifwelostoneofourown.”

　　Itclearlyshowswhenthelawyerstatestheabovewords,heknowsthatMr.Burrwasonlyanactor.SohisclaimofMr.Burrasoneofthemisonlyawaytopraisetheactor,butnottoaccepthimasacolleague.

　　Hence,ABCDhavenothingtodowiththeargumentthat"somelegalprofessionalsarelosingtheirabilitytodistinguishfictionfromreality".Inotherwords,ABCDareirrelevant.

　　Therefore,theonlycorrectanswerisE.

　　---------------------------------------------------------------

　　呃是这样的律师说“Althoughnotalawyer”就指E选项里面说的被忽略掉的part因为这清楚的表明他已经知道Mr.Burr不是演员也就是说他并没有将fiction和reality混淆